The Duke’s Reappearance by Thomas
A FAMILY TRADITION
According to the kinsman who told me the story, Christopher Swetman’s
house, on the outskirts of King’s-Hintock village, was in those
days larger and better kept than when, many years later, it was sold
to the lord of the manor adjoining; after having been in the Swetman
family, as one may say, since the Conquest.
Some people would have it to be that the thing happened at the house
opposite, belonging to one Childs, with whose family the Swetmans afterwards
intermarried. But that it was at the original homestead of the
Swetmans can be shown in various ways; chiefly by the unbroken traditions
of the family, and indirectly by the evidence of the walls themselves,
which are the only ones thereabout with windows mullioned in the Elizabethan
manner, and plainly of a date anterior to the event; while those of
the other house might well have been erected fifty or eighty years later,
and probably were; since the choice of Swetman’s house by the
fugitive was doubtless dictated by no other circumstance than its then
It was a cloudy July morning just before dawn, the hour of two having
been struck by Swetman’s one-handed clock on the stairs, that
is still preserved in the family. Christopher heard the strokes
from his chamber, immediately at the top of the staircase, and overlooking
the front of the house. He did not wonder that he was sleepless.
The rumours and excitements which had latterly stirred the neighbourhood,
to the effect that the rightful King of England had landed from Holland,
at a port only eighteen miles to the south-west of Swetman’s house,
were enough to make wakeful and anxious even a contented yeoman like
him. Some of the villagers, intoxicated by the news, had thrown
down their scythes, and rushed to the ranks of the invader. Christopher
Swetman had weighed both sides of the question, and had remained at
Now as he lay thinking of these and other things he fancied that
he could hear the footfall of a man on the road leading up to his house—a
byway, which led scarce anywhere else; and therefore a tread was at
any time more apt to startle the inmates of the homestead than if it
had stood in a thoroughfare. The footfall came opposite the gate,
and stopped there. One minute, two minutes passed, and the pedestrian
did not proceed. Christopher Swetman got out of bed, and opened
the casement. ‘Hoi! who’s there?’ cries he.
‘A friend,’ came from the darkness.
‘And what mid ye want at this time o’ night?’ says
‘Shelter. I’ve lost my way.’
‘What’s thy name?’
There came no answer.
‘Be ye one of King Monmouth’s men?’
‘He that asks no questions will hear no lies from me.
I am a stranger; and I am spent, and hungered. Can you let me
lie with you to-night?’
Swetman was generous to people in trouble, and his house was roomy.
‘Wait a bit,’ he said, ‘and I’ll come down and
have a look at thee, anyhow.’
He struck a light, put on his clothes, and descended, taking his
horn-lantern from a nail in the passage, and lighting it before opening
the door. The rays fell on the form of a tall, dark man in cavalry
accoutrements and wearing a sword. He was pale with fatigue and
covered with mud, though the weather was dry.
‘Prithee take no heed of my appearance,’ said the stranger.
‘But let me in.’
That his visitor was in sore distress admitted of no doubt, and the
yeoman’s natural humanity assisted the other’s sad importunity
and gentle voice. Swetman took him in, not without a suspicion
that this man represented in some way Monmouth’s cause, to which
he was not unfriendly in his secret heart. At his earnest request
the new-comer was given a suit of the yeoman’s old clothes in
exchange for his own, which, with his sword, were hidden in a closet
in Swetman’s chamber; food was then put before him and a lodging
provided for him in a room at the back.
Here he slept till quite late in the morning, which was Sunday, the
sixth of July, and when he came down in the garments that he had borrowed
he met the household with a melancholy smile. Besides Swetman
himself, there were only his two daughters, Grace and Leonard (the latter
was, oddly enough, a woman’s name here), and both had been enjoined
to secrecy. They asked no questions and received no information;
though the stranger regarded their fair countenances with an interest
almost too deep. Having partaken of their usual breakfast of ham
and cider he professed weariness and retired to the chamber whence he
In a couple of hours or thereabout he came down again, the two young
women having now gone off to morning service. Seeing Christopher
bustling about the house without assistance, he asked if he could do
anything to aid his host.
As he seemed anxious to hide all differences and appear as one of
themselves, Swetman set him to get vegetables from the garden and fetch
water from Buttock’s Spring in the dip near the house (though
the spring was not called by that name till years after, by the way).
‘And what can I do next?’ says the stranger when these
services had been performed.
His meekness and docility struck Christopher much, and won upon him.
‘Since you be minded to,’ says the latter, ‘you can
take down the dishes and spread the table for dinner. Take a pewter
plate for thyself, but the trenchers will do for we.’
But the other would not, and took a trencher likewise, in doing which
he spoke of the two girls and remarked how comely they were.
This quietude was put an end to by a stir out of doors, which was
sufficient to draw Swetman’s attention to it, and he went out.
Farm hands who had gone off and joined the Duke on his arrival had begun
to come in with news that a midnight battle had been fought on the moors
to the north, the Duke’s men, who had attacked, being entirely
worsted; the Duke himself, with one or two lords and other friends,
had fled, no one knew whither.
‘There has been a battle,’ says Swetman, on coming indoors
after these tidings, and looking earnestly at the stranger.
‘May the victory be to the rightful in the end, whatever the
issue now,’ says the other, with a sorrowful sigh.
‘Dost really know nothing about it?’ said Christopher.
‘I could have sworn you was one from that very battle!’
‘I was here before three o’ the clock this morning; and
these men have only arrived now.’
‘True,’ said the yeoman. ‘But still, I think—’
‘Do not press your question,’ the stranger urged.
‘I am in a strait, and can refuse a helper nothing; such inquiry
is, therefore, unfair.’
‘True again,’ said Swetman, and held his tongue.
The daughters of the house returned from church, where the service
had been hurried by reason of the excitement. To their father’s
questioning if they had spoken of him who sojourned there they replied
that they had said never a word; which, indeed, was true, as events
He bade them serve the dinner; and, as the visitor had withdrawn
since the news of the battle, prepared to take a platter to him upstairs.
But he preferred to come down and dine with the family.
During the afternoon more fugitives passed through the village, but
Christopher Swetman, his visitor, and his family kept indoors.
In the evening, however, Swetman came out from his gate, and, harkening
in silence to these tidings and more, wondered what might be in store
for him for his last night’s work.
He returned homeward by a path across the mead that skirted his own
orchard. Passing here, he heard the voice of his daughter Leonard
expostulating inside the hedge, her words being: ‘Don’t
ye, sir; don’t! I prithee let me go!’
‘Because I’ve a-promised another!’
Peeping through, as he could not help doing, he saw the girl struggling
in the arms of the stranger, who was attempting to kiss her; but finding
her resistance to be genuine, and her distress unfeigned, he reluctantly
let her go.
Swetman’s face grew dark, for his girls were more to him than
himself. He hastened on, meditating moodily all the way.
He entered the gate, and made straight for the orchard. When he
reached it his daughter had disappeared, but the stranger was still
‘Sir!’ said the yeoman, his anger having in no wise abated,
‘I’ve seen what has happened! I have taken ’ee
into my house, at some jeopardy to myself; and, whoever you be, the
least I expected of ’ee was to treat the maidens with a seemly
respect. You have not done it, and I no longer trust you.
I am the more watchful over them in that they are motherless; and I
must ask ’ee to go after dark this night!’
The stranger seemed dazed at discovering what his impulse had brought
down upon his head, and his pale face grew paler. He did not reply
for a time. When he did speak his soft voice was thick with feeling.
‘Sir,’ says he, ‘I own that I am in the wrong,
if you take the matter gravely. We do not what we would but what
we must. Though I have not injured your daughter as a woman, I
have been treacherous to her as a hostess and friend in need.
I’ll go, as you say; I can do no less. I shall doubtless
find a refuge elsewhere.’
They walked towards the house in silence, where Swetman insisted
that his guest should have supper before departing. By the time
this was eaten it was dusk and the stranger announced that he was ready.
They went upstairs to where the garments and sword lay hidden, till
the departing one said that on further thought he would ask another
favour: that he should be allowed to retain the clothes he wore, and
that his host would keep the others and the sword till he, the speaker,
should come or send for them.
‘As you will,’ said Swetman. ‘The gain is
on my side; for those clouts were but kept to dress a scarecrow next
‘They suit my case,’ said the stranger sadly. ‘However
much they may misfit me, they do not misfit my sorry fortune now!’
‘Nay, then,’ said Christopher relenting, ‘I was
too hasty. Sh’lt bide!’
But the other would not, saying that it was better that things should
take their course. Notwithstanding that Swetman importuned him,
he only added, ‘If I never come again, do with my belongings as
you list. In the pocket you will find a gold snuff-box, and in
the snuff-box fifty gold pieces.’
‘But keep ’em for thy use, man!’ said the yeoman.
‘No,’ says the parting guest; ‘they are foreign
pieces and would harm me if I were taken. Do as I bid thee.
Put away these things again and take especial charge of the sword.
It belonged to my father’s father and I value it much. But
something more common becomes me now.’
Saying which, he took, as he went downstairs, one of the ash sticks
used by Swetman himself for walking with. The yeoman lighted him
out to the garden hatch, where he disappeared through Clammers Gate
by the road that crosses King’s-Hintock Park to Evershead.
Christopher returned to the upstairs chamber, and sat down on his
bed reflecting. Then he examined the things left behind, and surely
enough in one of the pockets the gold snuff-box was revealed, containing
the fifty gold pieces as stated by the fugitive. The yeoman next
looked at the sword which its owner had stated to have belonged to his
grandfather. It was two-edged, so that he almost feared to handle
it. On the blade was inscribed the words ‘ANDREA FERARA,’
and among the many fine chasings were a rose and crown, the plume of
the Prince of Wales, and two portraits; portraits of a man and a woman,
the man’s having the face of the first King Charles, and the woman’s,
apparently, that of his Queen.
Swetman, much awed and surprised, returned the articles to the closet,
and went downstairs pondering. Of his surmise he said nothing
to his daughters, merely declaring to them that the gentleman was gone;
and never revealing that he had been an eye-witness of the unpleasant
scene in the orchard that was the immediate cause of the departure.
Nothing occurred in Hintock during the week that followed, beyond
the fitful arrival of more decided tidings concerning the utter defeat
of the Duke’s army and his own disappearance at an early stage
of the battle. Then it was told that Monmouth was taken, not in
his own clothes but in the disguise of a countryman. He had been
sent to London, and was confined in the Tower.
The possibility that his guest had been no other than the Duke made
Swetman unspeakably sorry now; his heart smote him at the thought that,
acting so harshly for such a small breach of good faith, he might have
been the means of forwarding the unhappy fugitive’s capture.
On the girls coming up to him he said, ‘Get away with ye, wenches:
I fear you have been the ruin of an unfortunate man!’
On the Tuesday night following, when the yeoman was sleeping as usual
in his chamber, he was, he said, conscious of the entry of some one.
Opening his eyes, he beheld by the light of the moon, which shone upon
the front of his house, the figure of a man who seemed to be the stranger
moving from the door towards the closet. He was dressed somewhat
differently now, but the face was quite that of his late guest in its
tragical pensiveness, as was also the tallness of his figure.
He neared the closet; and, feeling his visitor to be within his rights,
Christopher refrained from stirring. The personage turned his
large haggard eyes upon the bed where Swetman lay, and then withdrew
from their hiding the articles that belonged to him, again giving a
hard gaze at Christopher as he went noiselessly out of the chamber with
his properties on his arm. His retreat down the stairs was just
audible, and also his departure by the side door, through which entrance
or exit was easy to those who knew the place.
Nothing further happened, and towards morning Swetman slept.
To avoid all risk he said not a word to the girls of the visit of the
night, and certainly not to any one outside the house; for it was dangerous
at that time to avow anything.
Among the killed in opposing the recent rising had been a younger
brother of the lord of the manor, who lived at King’s-Hintock
Court hard by. Seeing the latter ride past in mourning clothes
next day, Swetman ventured to condole with him.
‘He’d no business there!’ answered the other.
His words and manner showed the bitterness that was mingled with his
regret. ‘But say no more of him. You know what has
happened since, I suppose?’
‘I know that they say Monmouth is taken, Sir Thomas, but I
can’t think it true,’ answered Swetman.
‘O zounds! ’tis true enough,’ cried the knight,
‘and that’s not all. The Duke was executed on Tower
Hill two days ago.’
‘D’ye say it verily?’ says Swetman.
‘And a very hard death he had, worse luck for ‘n,’
said Sir Thomas. ‘Well, ’tis over for him and over
for my brother. But not for the rest. There’ll be
searchings and siftings down here anon; and happy is the man who has
had nothing to do with this matter!’
Now Swetman had hardly heard the latter words, so much was he confounded
by the strangeness of the tidings that the Duke had come to his death
on the previous Tuesday. For it had been only the night before
this present day of Friday that he had seen his former guest, whom he
had ceased to doubt could be other than the Duke, come into his chamber
and fetch away his accoutrements as he had promised.
‘It couldn’t have been a vision,’ said Christopher
to himself when the knight had ridden on. ‘But I’ll
go straight and see if the things be in the closet still; and thus I
shall surely learn if ’twere a vision or no.’
To the closet he went, which he had not looked into since the stranger’s
departure. And searching behind the articles placed to conceal
the things hidden, he found that, as he had never doubted, they were
When the rumour spread abroad in the West that the man beheaded in
the Tower was not indeed the Duke, but one of his officers taken after
the battle, and that the Duke had been assisted to escape out of the
country, Swetman found in it an explanation of what so deeply mystified
him. That his visitor might have been a friend of the Duke’s,
whom the Duke had asked to fetch the things in a last request, Swetman
would never admit. His belief in the rumour that Monmouth lived,
like that of thousands of others, continued to the end of his days.
* * * * *
Such, briefly, concluded my kinsman, is the tradition which has been
handed down in Christopher Swetman’s family for the last two hundred